October 26, 2026

AI is a Terrible Master

 By Amy Barr with The Lukeion Project

Thomas Carlyle was a Scottish historian, writer, and teacher. He famously said, “Fire is the best of servants; but what a master!” Humans have always needed to cook a meal and heat a home but fear the day that fire might consume all they hold dear. Today we can say the same about AI (or SI, if you prefer).

We are past halfway through our autumn semester and the pressure is real. Students are confronted with multiple projects overlapping in various classes. Due dates loom. Add extra stress if fun opportunities are scheduled at the end of October. Most will rise to the occasion, push hard, and finish the tasks. Some students won’t…but will at least learn about how to manage their time a bit better. Realizing young that it takes more than an hour to write an excellent essay is some small benefit. Some students simply can’t. They let AI become their master without even thinking about it.  

For as long as teachers have taught students, there have been the first two groups. Given enough opportunity to mature executive function, those two groups usually merge, and everyone turns out just fine. It is only within the last few years that educators face the students who simply can’t. We aren’t talking about students who struggle with mental or physical health challenges. We are talking about students who gradually but surely handed over the bulk of their academic development to a handy “homework finisher” that enticingly came preinstalled on the very device where they finish their homework.

If you want to become physically fit, you don’t use a forklift to lift the weights for you. Repositioning weights is not the goal. By personally lifting incrementally heavier weights, you build a body that is ready for more extreme challenges as the years go by. The real work is in you, not the weights. 

Trouble starts with the casual habit of asking ChatGPT a question about the weather, history, or movie trivia: easy, fast, common, everyone does it! When the question is academic, the brain makes no distinction. Have a question? Just ask!

Week 1 homework means no fast obvious answers but a comfortable challenge level. Your educators start with light weights for the first mental lift. If you habitually do “your” thinking through AI, even these tasks will feel challenging. Not too long ago, people would browse a few websites, evaluate which answers were more trustworthy, and then draw conclusions. This activity replaced checking a dictionary or textual resource. Now we type in a question and voila! A confident and even definitive response pops up. This answer even has bullet points if we hit the “more” button. No need for further analysis. This “looks” trustworthy.

It took one minute to ask AI for the perfect answer, and it saved the student 20 minutes of mental effort. What a bargain! Maybe the student doesn’t even think of this as “using” AI per se as this is already a well-worn habit. They just handed over their intellectual future to the handy, helpful, and wide awake AI of their choice.

Compared to peers who put in the full 20-minute mental struggle to answer assigned questions at the beginning of the semester, the AI student has given himself a handicap that becomes more dangerous with every use. Peers who started with a relatively easy load, are now lifting 20-pound weights while the AI student has lifted nothing whatsoever. As the semester continues, peers are lifting 30, then 40, then 50 pounds. The AI student can’t do any of that. Classmates are becoming mentally fit at an accelerated rate while AI students develop nothing. The AI student advances grade-level because answers are technically correct but now in 12th grade, his skills are no better than 7th or 8th grade. College is about to be a massively expensive disaster.

Thomas Carlyle would surely agree, “AI is the best of servants; but what a master!”  Not using AI for your Lukeion classes is just the beginning. Try forcing yourself through the mental exercise of finding your answers to daily questions without constantly using that handy little helper. If you are already guilty of lifting too few mental loads, start again with easy weight demands. Start using old-timey things like resource materials or a library to rebuild your puny intellect. Your peers are well exercised and ready to keep moving forward. You may need to start again.

 

 

October 5, 2026

Curiosity Beats Confidence

By Amy Barr with The Lukeion Project

Is it true that there’s no such thing as a dumb question? Of course there are dumb questions. As a teacher I can guarantee that I’ve heard a few. You know what happened after somebody asked a dumb question? They got an answer and a better understanding of something that confused them. Life went on and and the whole world kept spinning. Everyone else went about their day not even thinking one moment about somebody else’s dumb question. Why do we worry?

There are plenty of dumb questions to be asked in a lifetime so stop worrying about the “quality” of the ones you have to ask. There will always be somebody who knows “better” than to ask that thing. There will always be somebody else who truly needs to hear the answer as well… but was too embarrassed to ask. Rather than appraising the quality of your queries while your opportunity disappears, let’s change how we look at the practice of asking questions. Being curious in a world of silent people is a superpower. 

Curiosity is the best predictor of success in education, relationships, and life. This is the secret that most people miss. Curious question-askers succeed to a far greater degree in almost every kind of challenge! Once you get rid of that anxious twinge you feel before asking questions, you will begin to advance.

Educators appreciate question-asking students because they are engaged and focused on the topic. Ask any educator the difference between a good class and a “bad” class. They’ll usually rate how engaged their students are during class time. Even one curious question-answer changes everything! I once had a student in my history class who was absolutely silent during every session. I was shocked to hear from his mother at the end that he loved the class. Silent students give the impression that they don’t care. If two students get an A+ in the same class ask for college recommendations, the one that asked more questions will get a better letter every time.

Humans love question-asking friends because such people are interested in others rather than in just themselves. Employers, co-workers, and employees love question-askers because a habit of voiced curiosity saves time, money, and energy for the whole company. Curiosity might have “killed the cat” but it builds human cooperation and community better than anything.   

When I first took Classical Greek in college, I worked hard to keep up with vocabulary, grammar, and forms. I was certain that if I kept quiet and kept working, it would all sort out in the end while I kept the appearance of somebody who is competent. Meanwhile one of my peers asked a zillion questions during the same classes where I sat silently. The exchange between this student and our professor helped everyone because he just didn’t care if his questions were dumb when he wanted to know the answer. Captain Question’s understanding of Greek advanced more rapidly than the rest of us. His relationship with the professor went from “that kid” that knew nothing at the start, to the professor’s colleague in language studies. Questions became an informed conversation about a shared interest.

Lesson learned! One person’s curiosity (and willingness to “look” dumb) sure did beat my approach. Trying to seem confident by not asking questions backfired and failed. I became a question-asker from then on.

Trying to appear confident is the best way to never feel confident. For appearance' sake, we don’t ask a fraction of the questions that we should ask as we mature. Certainly, one must read and listen to any instructions given. I’m not advocating skipping basic essentials. But there will nearly always be a gap in our understanding of anything that is new and even a little complex. Most humans would rather wing it to prevent giving anyone else the impression they don’t understand something they think must be a simple matter. They make that presumption based on the fact that nobody else is asking any questions. “I must be the only one that doesn’t get it,” is the start of various disaster scenarios.

Everyone silently trying to look confident and competent means your educator moves on to the next topic. A quick “dumb” question might save you—and everyone else—hours of confusion in an academic situation. A dumb question or two might also save relationships, jobs, and careers.

Part of becoming a successful mature adult is overcoming the desire to “seem” cool, confident, or knowledgeable at all costs because those costs become sizable before we know we are in debt.

If you consider how much asking questions can eventually make you really competent at things, you’ll understand the true meaning of the old saying, “there’s no such thing as a dumb question.” In the end, all you really risk by asking to understand something better is getting better at understanding.

Stay curious. Don’t stay silent.

AI is a Terrible Master

 By Amy Barr with The Lukeion Project Thomas Carlyle was a Scottish historian, writer, and teacher. He famously said, “Fire is the best of...